How to tell if a data breach notice is real or a scam
You often cannot tell from the message itself, and you do not need to. A genuine breach notice explains what happened, which of your data was involved and what the company is doing. It does not need you to click anything. A fake one usually pushes you to act now through a link, an attachment or a QR code. The reliable test is to ignore every link and phone number in the notice and check with the company through a route you already trust: its website typed by hand, its app, or the number on your card. If the breach is real, it will be confirmed there too. This works the same in the UK and the US.
Contents
Why do fake breach notices exist at all?
Because a real breach makes the perfect cover story. When a company announces a breach, its customers expect to hear from it. A message that claims to be that follow-up arrives at exactly the moment people are ready to act on it. The UK's National Cyber Security Centre, the NCSC, warns that criminals exploit high-profile breaches while they are still in the news. They impersonate the organisation that was breached and use stolen details to make their messages look personal.
That last point matters. If your name, email address or phone number was in the stolen data, the fake can quote it back to you. The NCSC also notes that these messages may arrive some time after the breach was made public. So a notice that is convincing and late is not proof of anything.
The tactic is not new, but it has become more polished. In March 2026 Techlicious described fake "your data was breached" emails that copy a company's logo, tone and security language, sometimes with help from AI writing tools. In September 2026 the US broadcaster WJAR reported fake breach letters and emails that carry a QR code, which is a square barcode that opens a web page when you scan it with a phone. Steve Weisman of Bentley University told the station that scammers use QR codes because email filters often miss the link hidden inside them.
What does a genuine notice contain?
A genuine notice explains. It does not ask. Both the UK and US rules describe a document that gives you information, rather than one that collects it from you.
In the UK, the Information Commissioner's Office, the ICO, says an organisation must tell people directly and without undue delay when a breach is likely to put them at high risk. The notice must describe the breach in clear and plain language. At a minimum it must include contact details for the data protection officer or another contact point, the likely consequences, and what the organisation has done or plans to do. The ICO also recommends specific advice, such as changing passwords or watching for phishing.
In the US, every state has its own breach notification law. California is the most detailed about format. Its Civil Code requires a notice in plain language titled Notice of Data Breach, with the headings What Happened?, What Information Was Involved?, What We Are Doing, What You Can Do and For More Information. It must list the types of data involved, the date or date range of the breach if known, the date of the notice and the company's contact details.
Two things follow from this. First, a genuine notice is specific. It names the kinds of data, the time frame and what the company has changed. Vague talk of "suspicious activity on your account" is not a breach notice. Second, an offer of free help is not itself a warning sign. California requires a company that caused the breach to offer identity theft protection at no cost for at least 12 months when certain data, such as Social Security numbers, was exposed. What counts is how you take up such an offer. Do it through the company's own website, not through a link in the message.
This is a summary of the rules for orientation. It is not legal advice.
Which signs point to a fake?
The strongest sign is a request. A fake wants something from you: a login, a payment, a form, a file opened. The NCSC lists messages about resetting passwords, receiving compensation or scanning your devices, heavy technical jargon, and pressure to act within a short deadline. It adds that your bank, or any other official organisation, will never ask you to supply personal information this way.
Other signs worth looking for:
- A sender address that looks almost right, with an extra word or an odd spelling in the domain. Techlicious names this as a common pattern.
- A button that takes you to a login page. Fake login pages capture the password you type.
- An attachment that claims to hold "the details of the breach". That is a common way to deliver malware.
- A QR code in an email or a letter.
- A request for your full card number, your password or a Social Security or National Insurance number "to verify your identity".
None of these signs is proof on its own, and a good fake may show none of them. That is why the check in the next section matters more than any list of warning signs.
How do you check a notice without clicking anything?
Take a second route to the company, one that does not start in the message. The NCSC advises confirming through the organisation's official website or social media accounts, not through links or contact details in the message. The US Federal Trade Commission, the FTC, gives the same advice: contact the company using a phone number or website you know is real.
In practice that means one of three things. Type the company's address into your browser yourself. Open its app, if you already have it installed. Or call the number on the back of your card, on a past bill or on a statement. A company that sends out breach notices normally publishes a statement on its own website as well. Techlicious notes that genuine notices tend to arrive through several channels, rather than through a single urgent link.
You can also look up your email address on Have I Been Pwned, a free service that collects the data from known breaches. The NCSC names it as one way to see whether your details appear in other breaches. It will not list every incident, so a clean result does not prove a notice is fake.
The whole check takes a few minutes. If the company's own channels say nothing about a breach, treat the notice as a fake until you hear otherwise.
Is a breach on a government website always real?
Not always. Maine publishes the breach notices that companies file with it, and researchers and reporters use the list as a source. In June 2026 that system was abused. A notice in the name of VRChat, a social platform, appeared on the Maine Attorney General's public portal. It claimed that a hack in May had exposed data on more than 2.4 million users. VRChat told BleepingComputer that it had not filed the notice and that the employee named in it did not exist. A second fake claimed to be from Discord and spoke of 10 million people. It gave a Gmail contact address and a customer notification date of 1 January 2000.
The office told BleepingComputer that anyone could submit the form without verification, and that it had no independent knowledge of the breaches reported. According to The Record, it called the notices hoaxes and took the public database offline while it reviewed its procedures.
For you, this means a link to an "official" listing is not a substitute for the company's own word. A scammer can point to an entry like this as proof. The company's website remains the place to check.
The notice is real. What now?
Read what it says was taken, and act on that. If passwords were involved, change the password for that service. Then change it anywhere else you used the same one, because a reused password is the main way one breach turns into several. The NCSC also suggests a passkey where the service offers one. If a notice says the passwords were "hashed", our piece on what hashed passwords in a breach notice really mean explains how much protection that gives.
A new password is not always enough. Sessions that are already signed in can stay open after the change, which is why we explained separately why changing your password does not log the attacker out. Look at the list of connected apps as well, since apps with access to your Google, Apple or Microsoft account keep their own key.
Then expect follow-up messages. A real breach is the moment when the fakes start. The NCSC advises checking your accounts for signs of misuse, such as changed security settings or logins from unusual places or times. If money has gone, contact your bank straight away.
Where do you report a fake notice?
Forward it, then delete it. In the UK, forward suspicious emails to the NCSC at report@phishing.gov.uk and suspicious texts to 7726, which is free. The NCSC says it analyses each email and the websites it links to. If you lost money, report it to Report Fraud at reportfraud.police.uk, or to the police on 101 in Scotland.
In the US, the FTC asks you to forward phishing emails to the Anti-Phishing Working Group at reportphishing@apwg.org, to forward texts to 7726, which spells SPAM, and to report the attempt at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. If the fake used a real company's name, that company will usually want to know as well. Tell it through the contact page on its own website.
Sources
- Data breaches: guidance for individuals and families, National Cyber Security Centre, published 28 January 2021 and updated May 2026, for how criminals exploit breaches, the warning signs, the advice to check through official channels, Have I Been Pwned, passkeys, account checks and the UK reporting routes
- Report a scam email, National Cyber Security Centre, for the reporting address and what the NCSC does with reports
- How to recognize and avoid phishing scams, Federal Trade Commission, for contacting the company through a known website or number and the US reporting routes
- Personal data breaches: a guide, Information Commissioner's Office, for when organisations must tell individuals and what the notice must contain under the UK GDPR
- California Civil Code section 1798.82, California Legislature, text via california.public.law, for the title, headings, required contents and the offer of identity theft protection
- California Code, Civil Code § 1798.82, FindLaw, for the title and headings of California notices
- State Data Breach Notification Laws: Overview of the Patchwork, Jackson Lewis, 9 April 2018, for breach notification laws in all 50 states
- Scammers Are Now Sending Fake 'Your Data Was Breached' Emails, Techlicious, 16 March 2026, for the appearance of fake notices, lookalike sender domains and genuine notices arriving through several channels
- Scammers exploiting data breach fears with fake notices and QR codes, NBC 10 News (WJAR), 10 September 2026, for fake breach letters with QR codes and the comments by Steve Weisman
- Maine breach portal abused to publish fake data breach disclosures, BleepingComputer, 11 June 2026, for the fake VRChat and Discord notices and the statements by VRChat and the Maine Attorney General's office
- Maine Closes Its Data Breach Portal to the Public After Fake Reports, The Record, 15 June 2026, for the hoax statement and the removal of public access to the database